Tuesday, June 6, 2023

Interpretive Communities in Stanley Fish — Definition and Examples

An interpretive community, in Stanley Fish’s account, is formed by shared ways of reading that guide what counts as a text, a relevant detail or a convincing interpretation. People can use the same interpretive strategies without consciously agreeing on them. They learn the strategies through practices such as studying literature, taking part in an institution or reading with others.

Two classrooms, one list

Imagine two classrooms with the same list of words on the board. One class has been asked to edit a reading list and looks for authors, titles or missing information. Another has been told the list is a poem and looks for repetitions, allusions and patterns. Each class can point to details on the board. What the details count as evidence for depends on what the readers are doing. Fish makes a related point in How to Recognize a Poem When You See One.

This example is based on Fish’s experiment in How to Recognize a Poem When You See One. He shows how a class trained in religious poetry could find biblical patterns in a list another class used as an assignment.

Why agreement and disagreement are possible

Members of a community can disagree about a reading while sharing ways of judging it. Two students may dispute an allusion but agree about what kind of evidence would count. Readers can also learn a new practice and start to notice features that previously seemed beside the point. Communities overlap and their practices can change.

Where the idea fits in Fish’s work

The title essay of Is There a Text in This Class? shows how a situation can make the same question intelligible in different ways. The summary of the collection puts that argument alongside Fish’s essays on literary reading. For a wider introduction, see Stanley Fish’s Reader-Response Theory.

Further reading · Stanley Fish and Roland Barthes · Fish and Dworkin on Legal Interpretation · Fish on Law, Politics and Literature · Fish on Boutique Multiculturalism