Sunday, April 28, 2019

Kierkegaard on passion and pathos (summary and quotes)


For Kierkegaard, in order to apprehend the absolute, the mind must radically empty itself of objective content. What supports this radical emptying, however, is the desire for the absolute. Kierkegaard names this desire Passion.

According to Kierkegaard, the human self desires that which is beyond reason. Desire itself appears to be a desire for the infinite, as Plato once wrote. Even the desire to propagate, according to Plato, is a kind of desire for immortality—that is, we wish to live on in time through our children and their children. Erotic love itself appears as an example of this desire for something beyond the purely finite. It is a taste of what could be, if only it could continue beyond the boundaries of time and space. As the analogy implies, humans seek something beyond the here and now. The question remains, however, why is it that human pathos or passion is the most precious thing? In some ways, it might have to do with our status as existential beings. It is not thought that gets us through life—it is action; and what motivates and sustains action is passion, the desire to overcome hardships, pain, and suffering. It is also passion that enables us to die for ideals in the name of a higher reality. While a scientist might see this as plain emotion or simple animal desire, Kierkegaard sees it as that which binds to the source of life itself. The desire to live, and to live in the right way, for the right reasons, and with the right desires, is a holy and sacred force. For Kierkegaard all Christian action should have its ground in love, which is a passion.

If anyone is unwilling to learn from Christianity to love himself in the right way, he cannot love the neighbor either. He can perhaps hold together with another or a few other persons, “through thick and thin,” as it is called, but this is by no means loving the neighbor. To love yourself in the right way and to love the neighbor correspond perfectly to one another, fundamentally they are one and the same thing. When the Law’s as yourself has wrested from you the self-love that Christianity sadly enough must presuppose to be in every human being, then you actually have learned to love yourself. The Law is therefore: you shall love yourself in the same way as you love your neighbor when you love him as yourself. Whoever has any knowledge of people will certainly admit that just as he has often wished to be able to move them to relinquish self-love, he has also had to wish that it were possible to teach them to love themselves. When the bustler wastes his time and powers in the service of the futile, inconsequential pursuits, is that not because he has not learned rightly to love himself? When the light-minded person throws himself almost like a nonentity into the folly of the moment and makes nothing of it, is this not because he does not know how to love himself rightly? When the depressed person desires to be rid of life, indeed of himself, is this not because he is unwilling to learn earnestly and rigorously to love himself? When someone surrenders to despair because the world or another person has faithlessly left him betrayed, what then is his fault (his innocent suffering is not referred to here) except not loving himself in the right way? When someone self-tormentingly thinks to do God a service by torturing himself, what is his sin except not willing to love himself in the right way? And if, alas, a person presumptuously lays violent hands upon himself, is not his sin precisely this, that he does not rightly love himself in the sense in which a person ought to love himself? Oh, there is a lot of talk in the world about treachery, and faithlessness, and, God help us, it is unfortunately all too true, but still let us never because of this forget that the most dangerous traitor of all is the one every person has within himself. This treachery whether it consists in selfishly loving oneself or consists in selfishly not willing to love oneself in the right way – this treachery is admittedly a secret. No cry is raised as it usually is in the case of treachery and faithlessness. But is it not therefore all the more important that Christianity’s doctrine should be brought to mind again and again, that a person shall love his neighbor as himself, that is as he ought to love himself? … You shall love – this, then is the word of the royal Law. Works of Love,  p. 22-24
One can also look at this from the perspective of what the meaning of our existence is. Why suffer what humans have suffered, the pain and despair—what meaning can all of this have? For Kierkegaard, there is no meaning unless passion, the emotions and will of humans, has a divine source.

Passion is closely aligned with faith in Kierkegaard's thought. Faith as a passion is what drives humans to seek reality and truth in a transcendent world, even though everything we can know intellectually speaks against it. To live and die for a belief, to stake everything one has and is in the belief in something that has a higher meaning than anything in the world—this is belief and passion at their highest.

Kierkegaard wrote of the subjective thinker's task in his Concluding Unscientific Postscript . Intellectual reason had been deified by Hegel in his theology and Kierkegaard felt this would lead to the objectification of religion.

There is an old proverb: oratio, tentatio, meditatio, faciunt theologum [prayer, trial, meditation, make a theologian]. Similarly, for a subjective thinker, imagination, feeling and dialectics in impassioned existence-inwardness are required. But first and last, passion, because for an existing person it is impossible to think about existence without becoming passionate, inasmuch as existing is a prodigious contradiction from which the subjective thinker is not to abstract, for then it is easy, but in which he is to remain. In a world-historical dialectic, individuals fade away into humankind; in a dialectic such as that it is impossible to discover you and me, an individual existing human being, even if new magnifying glasses for the concrete are invented. The subjective thinker is a dialectician oriented to the existential; he has the intellectual passion to hold firm the qualitative disjunction. But, on the other hand, if the qualitative disjunction is used flatly and simply, if it is applied altogether abstractly to the individual human being, then one can run the ludicrous risk of saying something infinitely decisive, and of being right in what one says, and still not say the least thing. Therefore, in the psychological sense it is really remarkable to see the absolute disjunction deceitfully used simply for evasion. When the death penalty is placed on every crime, the result is that no crimes at all are punished. It is the same with the absolute disjunction when applied flatly and simply; it is just like a silent letter-it cannot be pronounced or, if it can be pronounced, it says nothing. The subjective thinker, therefore, has with intellectual passion the absolute disjunction as belonging to existence, but he has it as the final decision that prevents everything from ending in a quantifying. Thus he has it readily available, but not in such a way that by abstractly recurring to it, he just frustrates existence. The subjective thinker, therefore, has also esthetic passion and ethical passion, whereby concretion is gained. All existence-issues are passionate, because existence, if one becomes conscious of it, involves passion. To think about them so as to leave out passion is not to think about them at all, is to forget the point that one indeed is oneself and existing person. Yet the subjective thinker is not a poet even if he is also a poet, not an ethicist even if he is also an ethicist, but is also a dialectician and is himself essentially existing, whereas the poet’s existence is inessential in relation to the poem, and likewise the ethicist’s in relation to the teaching, and the dialectician’s in relation to the thought. The subjective thinker is not a scientist-scholar; he is an artist. To exist is an art. The subjective thinker is esthetic enough for his life to have esthetic content, ethical enough to regulate it, dialectical enough in thinking to master it. The subjective thinker’s task is to understand himself in existence. p. 350-351 



13 comments:

  1. I love this blog. A Metal Roofing Sheets is a roofing system made from metal pieces provided by high resistance. It is a component of the building envelope. Metal Roofing in Chennai offer you a best contractors and suppliers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing, nice article!. Thank you.
    Khách hàng sẽ cảm thấy hài lòng khi sử dụng những dịch vụ như: vận tải bắc nam, dịch vụ bốc xếp, chuyển phát nhanh, cho thuê xe tải, ship cod,... của Proship. Chúng tôi đảm bảo hàng hóa quá khách hàng luôn được an toàn trong quá trình vận chuyển, thời gian vận chuyển nhanh nhất, giá rẻ nhất.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good artical
    the useful information the article the artical is simplest language i have read your blog and good valuable information . Information about Rattu Tota free govt. job was just amazing.
    now i am the following blog information

    ReplyDelete
  4. Aw, this was a very nice post. Taking the time and actual effort to produce a superb article… but what can Psychology Hack Reverse Psychology say…

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very well explained and informative blog click here for
    Quickbooks for Mac Support Phone Number for more detail dial on 844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  6. JSC Result Dinajpur Board 2019. Dinajpur education board is one of the 9 general education boards in the country. In general, a lot of students have participated in the JSC exam under this Dinajpur board. JSC Result Dinajpur Board will be published soon. But do you know how to get results? if you don’t know, here is the guideline to get it.

    JSC Result 2019 Chittagong Board Bangladesh: Are you looking for JSC Result 2019 then the piece of article will be helpful for you. Here you will get JSC & JDC Result. The word JSC and JDC is the short form of Junior School Certificate (JSC) and Junior Dakhil Certificate (JDC).

    JSC Result 2019 Sylhet Board with Marksheet: Hello, dear JSC Examine! Here is Sylhet Board JSC Result 2019. Do you know when Sylhet Board JSC Exam Result 2019 com will be published? Well, I know. In this article, we’ll let you know about all information about JSC Result Sylhet board.

    JSC Result 2019 Comilla Board. JSC examinations were also held in Comilla board like other Educational boards in Bangladesh. So you must be waiting for JSC Result Comilla Board like every people. At the same time, you are searching for the way on how to see the JSC Comilla Board Results. Today we want to put an end to your entire search.

    JSC Result 2019 Barisal Board Online with Marksheet. Barisal Board has a good reputation for the JSC and other public Exam results. It is said that passing in the exam is very easy from this board no matter it is the JSC, SSC or HSC exam.

    I think you are looking for JSC Result 2019 Jessore Board. In this article, I will show you how to get JSC result 2019 of Jessore Education Board. In this year the Junior School Certificate (as known JSC) exam will start from 1st November.

    You Can Check JDC Result 2019 by Online and SMS. Also Others Few Method Available but Those two are most Popular. Madrasah Education Board is Special Education Board In Bangladesh.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Halo,I'm Helena Julio from Ecuador,I want to talk good about Le_Meridian Funding Service on this topic.Le_Meridian Funding Service gives me financial support when all bank in my city turned down my request to grant me a loan of 500,000.00 USD, I tried all i could to get a loan from my banks here in Ecuador but they all turned me down because my credit was low but with god grace I came to know about Le_Meridian so I decided to give a try to apply for the loan. with God willing they grant me  loan of 500,000.00 USD the loan request that my banks here in Ecuador has turned me down for, it was really awesome doing business with them and my business is going well now. Here is Le_Meridian Funding Investment Email/WhatsApp Contact if you wish to apply loan from them.Email:lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com / lfdsloans@outlook.comWhatsApp Contact:+1-989-394-3740.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Very nice and well explained blog click here for
    QuickBooks support phone number to get the solution of QuickBooks issues and for more detail dial on our support number 844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  9. The concept of pre-school evolved and grown to new heights in the last two decades. Today, people are eyeing the pre-school franchise as an excellent small-scale business which can fetch you good profits if managed effectively. These Play School Franchise is coming with low investments as such schools are automatically designed by the Franchiser. In this article we would provide Top 10 Play School Franchise in India that can be started with low investment and can provide high profits.
    Preschool Franchise


    How to start a preschool


    How to start a playschool


    Best Play school Franchise


    Best Preschool Franchise

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow! this is Amazing! Do you know your hidden name meaning ? Click here to find your hidden name meaning

    ReplyDelete
  11. We are one of the authorized people for bus branding in Chennai metropolitan across Tamilnadu. Bus Back Panel Advertising in Chennai, MTC - Chennai City Bus Advertisement, Bus Advertising Agency, Bus Ad Agency, Bus branding in Tamil Nadu, Bus back advertising size, Bus back advertising Chennai, Bus back advertising cost in Chennai, Government bus advertising, Bus advertising rates in Chennai

    Bus Ad Agency Chennai

    ReplyDelete

script async src="//pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js">