Pages

▼

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

What Is Diasporic Identity? Stuart Hall on Identity as Positioning

When Stuart Hall visited Martinique, what struck him was how different it felt from Jamaica. He had grown up in Kingston and recognised much in the French Caribbean. There was also a great deal he could only understand by paying attention to a different colonial history. From the vantage point of a European metropolis, both islands could be treated as part of the same periphery. From either island, the differences mattered. Hall uses the comparison to ask what we mean when we say a people has a cultural identity.

In Cultural Identity and Diaspora, diasporic identity is a way of belonging formed through dispersal and through the histories people make in the places where they settle. You can inherit a memory or a language and still have to learn what it means in a new setting. Hall calls this positioning. Institutions, images and inherited stories place us in relation to others. We also take up positions of our own when we tell those stories back.


What a shared past can do

Hall gives real weight to the idea that a people might recognise itself through a shared history. An empire can teach people to regard their past as unworthy of study. Recovering names, stories and practices that official histories have dismissed gives people grounds for solidarity. It also changes what can be imagined in the present. The first account of identity in Hall’s essay starts from that experience of recognition.

Consider what had to happen for a common Caribbean past to take shape. The people forced across the Atlantic came from different places and spoke different languages. Enslavement, displacement and plantation labour created conditions in which they made new forms of life together. The history that people share includes the break that brought them into relation in the first place. This is why Hall treats continuity and rupture as two parts of the same story. The second account of identity asks how people came to inherit a shared past, and what that inheritance lets them do now.


Who gets to name the position?

A person can claim to be Black and British in the same sentence. Whether those words sound entirely ordinary or seem to require an explanation depends on who is listening and on the history of the institutions in which the claim is made. An official category may offer one answer. A family memory, a political movement or a film may offer another. The person speaking has some room to act, and the conditions under which they will be heard have already been shaped by others.

This is the useful distinction in Hall’s idea of positioning. It gives us a way to ask what people do with the identities they inherit while keeping the history of those identities in view. In Old and New Identities, Old and New Ethnicities, Hall follows this problem into debates about Britishness and the forms of belonging available to people who grew up inside more than one tradition.

Return to the two islands. Hall can say that Martinicans and Jamaicans share a Caribbean history and that they occupy different positions within it. The scale at which we look changes what comes into focus. So does the place from which we speak. A good account of diasporic identity has room for both observations.

For more of Hall’s work on race, culture and representation, see our guide to Stuart Hall’s theory and works.

Stuart Hall, “Cultural Identity and Diaspora”, in Identity: Community, Culture, Difference, ed. Jonathan Rutherford (1990), pp. 222–237, especially pp. 225–228.